Bad news: national security train wreck!
June 12, 2013 5 Comments
As a result of the deeply damaging Snowden leak, I am reminded of the principles that make me more of a security hawk than my libertarian compatriots.
Dan Mitchell at International Liberty staked a respectable position regarding the still-unfolding NSA surveillance story. But some of the comments from his more ardent libertarian readers are real forehead-slappers. Like the proposition that our military should consist solely of a Coast Guard and maybe an army reserve.
It seems to me that civil liberties advocates tend to have it half-right. Judeo-Christian tradition informs the concept of Natural Law in many ways: we are equal in dignity before our Creator because we bear His image. We ought to be suspicious of those in authority because they, like all created persons, are sinful. Even the best of us are blinded by pride or tempted to abuse. Indeed, this is the clearest argument from the Christian worldview against centralized, progressive technocracies.
But the forgotten half of Judeo-Christian anthropology is that there are and will always be actors–states, individuals, movements–bent on destroying our government, killing our people, and weakening our society.
On this myopia, I’m reminded of Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged. Its villains, who would wreck American civilization, were either bumbling bleeding hearts or homegrown totalitarians. Socialism and central planning were alive and well in Rand’s imagination, but the threat of international communism was nowhere to be found. Rather strange for a book released in 1957, the year Sputnik was launched, the year after Khrushchev barked “We will bury you!” and four years after the Soviets acquired the hydrogen bomb, thanks of course to the traitorous Julius Rosenberg.
There is no Soviet Union today, but between Putin’s desperately declining Russia, the unscrupulous authoritarians running the People’s Republic of China, the bottomless supply of Islamist terrorists, and the Pandora’s box of asymmetric capabilities at everyone’s disposal, today’s world is hardly Mr Rogers’ Neighborhood. Big data is everywhere, and we sure as well better have the good guys using it, because the bad guys definitely are.
Former attorney general Michael Mukasey couldn’t have put it better when he wrote in a recent op-ed :
The Constitution and U.S. laws are not a treaty with the universe; they protect U.S. citizens. Foreign governments spy on us and our citizens. We spy on them and theirs. Welcome to the world.
I’ve given a piece of my mind on intel leakers in the past. Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden are the bratty poster children for a grave generational defect. The simple reality is that our nation’s security is in the hands of Millennials, whose self-defined attributes include a sharply liberal political bent and “superior intelligence” according to a 2010 Pew poll.
Snowden’s affinities, as revealed in a Guardian interview, gel with his cohort. He’s more cosmopolitan than patriotic:
“There are conflicts between the United States government and the Chinese PRC government, but the peoples inherently… we don’t care, we trade with each other freely, we are not at war, we’re not in armed conflict and we’re not trying to be. We’re the largest trading partners out there for each other.”
Cue Lennon’s Imagine. The view is gravely misinformed. Acts of conscience don’t do much good when the premisses are flat out wrong.
And speaking of China, how did President Obama’s California summit with President Xi go? I’m sure we made a sterling show of strength, unity, and integrity. Peace through Strength, and the Shining City on a Hill. That’s Reagan, not our bumbling Obama.
Then again, China may have had a hand in this surveillance program compromise all along. Or, with publicly aired allegations of US hacking, maybe US-China relations will be severely set back. Certainly, terrorists have gotten a little wiser about avoiding detection. Any which way you cut it, nothing good comes out of this fiasco. There is no way Snowden could possibly be a hero.
It’s beyond frustrating that such undisciplined, uninformed flunkies stumble into treason. Who knows how many more Mannings and Snowdens have access to secrets and are all-too-willing to spill the beans? That, not any NSA surveillance overreach, is what should keep us up at night.